Wide Web Crypto

The web is the distribution. Crypto is the argument about settlement.

Ethereum upgrade test: a transaction succeeds while an internal payment fails

Tests reported on November 17, 2026, raised a settlement risk for the proposed Ethereum upgrade Glamsterdam: on the Sepolia test network, a Juicebox payment contract could complete an outer transaction even when an internal payment failed. The findings concerned a proposed change under test, not an enacted mainnet rule.

What the Juicebox tests showed

According to Juicebox’s technical documentation, an NFT buyer received the NFT in one test even though an internal payment to an associated project ran out of gas. The unpaid funds remained in the paying project. In a token-distribution test, a reserved token allocation completed, but a cross-project payment did not. The beneficiary received the original project’s tokens instead of the intended cross-project payment result.

Ethereum upgrade test: a transaction succeeds while an internal payment fails (1)

A cash-redemption test found another consequence: within a reported range of 679,622 to 817,622 gas, users could redeem funds while an internal 2.5% protocol fee payment failed.

Ethereum upgrade test: a transaction succeeds while an internal payment fails (2)

Why the failure was easy to miss

Juicebox developer mejango linked the behavior to changes in gas costs and the contract’s error handling. Under the tested rules, proposed EIP-8037 substantially raises the cost of creating state and writing new storage. An internal payment can therefore run out of gas before the surrounding transaction does. The contract’s try/catch handling catches that internal failure, allowing the outer transaction to continue and be confirmed.

Ethereum upgrade test: a transaction succeeds while an internal payment fails (3)

In comparable mainnet simulations, the developers reported that transactions in the same gas range either failed as a whole or completed the payment; they did not observe an internal payment being skipped. The contrast matters for existing contracts, particularly those that cannot be upgraded and whose gas allowances and error handling were designed around earlier costs.

As of the November 17 report, the Ethereum Foundation had placed the Juicebox report and proof-of-concept material on the agenda for a November 19 meeting to examine the findings and possible responses, including comparison with work on EIP-8038. No final decision on changing proposal parameters had been reported.